Monday, July 15, 2013

Mixcraft vs Reaper vs Audacity

UPDATE: Mixcraft 6.1 as far as DAWS go is a very good DAW. 6 had issues typical of most of today's DAWS. Acoustica now makes a respectable DAW that is very easy to learn and it has a great workflow. While I don't recommend any DAW software I can safely say that if you like DAWs, Mixcraft 6.1 will not disappoint and Reaper still sucks.

CLICK HERE TO LEARN WHY TO AVOID TUNECORE

This is from Acoustic Guitar Forum

A newbie asks:

I'm looking at learning a DAW for solo acoustc guitar only. MIxcraft looks like it might be the most user-freindly; Reaper seems to get the best overall reviews, and Audacity is free. I'm leaning toward Mixcraft if that would greatly minimize the learning curve!
Any suggestions or comments? 


Here are the responses:


Reaper ... by a long shot! You can evaluate a 100% functional, non-expiring copy of Reaper for free, and only register when you decide it's what you need (just $40 ... a real steal). I use it extensively. I've added EZDrummer for percussion, and it works seamlessly with Reaper.

Audacity doesn't come close.  



For just solo guitar any of them will work, Audacity is not bad for one or 2 instruments but does not support VST effects very well.

Mixcraft has a timing problem, it drifts something bad as the song progresses....and yes, I am talking about the newest version also.

Reaper s much better, but a larger learning curve.....

There is another DAW that slips under the radar a lot by Zynewave called Podium that has a very workable Free version. I felt the included effects were fine, and it was pretty easy to figure out....plus the price is right!


Are you using Audacity 1.3.x beta when you have issues with the VST support? I'm getting the full UI with VSTs I've installed in the latest beta version, which is the one recommended by the devs.

I'd heard a glancing mention of the Mixcraft timing issue but foolishly _assumed_ that it only applied to MIDI. Sounds pretty annoying.

I came from Adobe Audition/Cool Edit Pro and my recording was limited to using the two track editor for a number of years. Man, was I doing things the hard way <grin>. The first time I tried REAPER I couldn't grasp the concept at all.

Just as I started transitioning to the multi-track non-destructive way of editing in AA I ran into a snag with Adobe's license validation process and it made me so mad I became determined to learn to use REAPER. Fortunately I found a number of free video tutorials which got me over the first humps and I made the switch without significant self-inflicted injury.

A long winded way of saying that the user created resources for REAPER are pretty wonderful and can help ease the learning a lot.

Fran 


Reaper sucks. The native plugins are horrible and unusable and when you install a plugin Reaper crashes. Reaper is ugly, unstable and difficult to learn. Mixcraft wins by a mile. -Mark-

Mixcraft mentions timing of some computers here
http://www.acoustica.com/mixcraft/v4/help/hs1550.htm


Audacity is what I used originally, and it's ok for getting ideas down. However, REAPER is awesome, and relatively user friendly. It takes a little learning, but so does Audacity; and once you start learning REAPER you're already starting to put that time and knowledge into a program that professionals use.     Eli

I've used both and now I am using Mixcraft. Reaper crashes and freezes to the point it is worthless. Reaper is also bare bones and to get it to where it has enough plugins you have to pay through the ass because the free plugins and loops suck and many of the are not compatible with Reaper aka Raper.

Reaper is just some shitty software that remains in perpetual buggy beta mode.


Reaper crashes constantly... - Cockos Confederated Forums

forum.cockos.com › REAPER Forums › newbieland

Sep 7, 2008 - 12 posts - ‎5 authors
I was editing a drum track I made in EZ Drummer and putting in a new mix of these tracks when Reaper started to crash all the time, even if I ...

Reaper crashes a lot, help is appreciated : Reaper - Reddit

https://www.reddit.com/.../Reaper/.../reaper_crashes_a_lot_help_is_...

reddit
Jan 6, 2015 - Okay so, I've recently tracked my bands debut album. I've been mixing the songs for two days now (whee) and the software keeps crashing or ...

Reaper Crashing Constantly - Songcrafters.org

songcrafters.org › ... › Home Recording › DAW & Music Software

Apr 5, 2011 - 6 posts - ‎3 authors
Reaper Crashing Constantly DAW & Music Software.

Reaper keeps crashing constantly because of EZDrummer ...

www.sevenstring.org › ... › Music Discussion › Recording Studio

Sep 28, 2011 - 6 posts - ‎4 authors
For the past few weeks Reaper has been working perfectly fine, but now, every time I open it and load my project, it crashes immediately after ...

UG Community @ Ultimate-Guitar.Com - Reaper crashing constantly?

www.ultimate-guitar.com/.../showthread.php?t...

Ultimate Guitar Archive
Feb 27, 2012 - 6 posts - ‎4 authors
Does anyone else have a problem with Reaper crashing a lot? It's not even necessarily specific plugins that make it crash, it'll sometimes just ...

HELP - Reaper Crashing in Windows 7 - using M-Audio Fast Track Pro ...

www.progressiveears.org › ... › Artists' Forum

Feb 16, 2013 - 9 posts - ‎5 authors
I have been using Reaper for over a year on a very old PC (Windows XP) with M-Audio Fast track pro and everything had been working fine.

REAPER Crashes When Inserting Plugins? | The REAPER ...

reaperblog.net/2012/02/reaper-crashes-when-inserting-plugins/

Feb 9, 2012 - For a while REAPER has been crashing often when I insert a plugin. This is NOT normal behavior and not what I am used to seeing. After a ...

Reaper Crashes when VST's LOad - Future Producers forums

www.futureproducers.com › ... › DAW Sequencers / Samplers (Software)

Sep 13, 2007 - As anyone figured this out??? Reaper (In my Opinion) is freaking sweet but every time I load a VST from WAVES it freezes up and crashes......

Game constantly crashing on derelict reaper level - PC Technical ...

forum.bioware.com › ... › Archived › PC Technical Support

Feb 8, 2010 - 8 posts - ‎4 authors
I make it about five minutes into the core portion of it before it crashes. Tried running it in windowed mode with the graphics seetings turned all ...

REAPER 4.0 is out!!!!! - Page 4 - Gearslutz.com

https://www.gearslutz.com/board/music.../636038-reaper-4-0-out-4.html

Aug 5, 2011 - Only Reaper crashes on me, even with a lot fewer plugins installed. ..... use Reaper if its crashing constantly, I wouldnt torture myself like that.



Here is a side by side comparison of Reaper vs Mixcraft

 


11 comments:

  1. Hey PFA,

    Another sleazy company is XLN audio the seller of Addictive Drums. Please expose those fucking cocksuckers they way you have Acoustica.

    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mixcraft beats the shit of of Reaper in one resepect. The plug ins in Reaper are mostly garbage and before you can really use Reaper you need to put in decent effect and amp models but good luck with that. It's a major pain in the ass.

    Reaper is no deal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Reaper sucks more than Mixcraft

      Delete
    2. Reaper's plugins are among the cleanest and most cpu efficient I know. They aren't beautiful, they doesn't color the sound but they do the job and they do it well. They only weak point would be the reverb.

      Delete
    3. Reaper plugins sound like shit and I mean no disrespect to shit and they turn an already unstable DAW into a fucking worse nightmare.

      Delete
  3. It's not Addictive Drums. Sure it's buggy but not as buggy as Reaper. Reaper is $40. You get what you pay for.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, Reaper, inspite of all hype from the geeks becomes untsable and unusable when you add plugins even good ones.

      Reaper is betaware like most DAWS.

      Delete
    2. I have tons of plugins and I almost never had a crash (I use Reaper every day), except with one plugin, and it's a vst that cause problems with other daws too. Personally I think you definitely don't always get what you pay for. College gave me ProTools 11 and Digital Performer... but I still use Reaper, especially since the 4.5 update which made it one of the best DAWs for MIDI (before it was the weak point).

      Delete
    3. You may be the exception that proves the rule.

      Hopefully this upgrade will make Reaper and acceptable DAW but so far is stinks on ice.

      Delete
  4. Reaper is far worse than Mixcraft. It has a horrible learning curve, it's nearly as unstable and the VST sucks ass.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mixcraft is vastly improved and Reaper aka Raper still sucks ass.

      Delete